Comparing Therapy Approaches: RDI, Floortime, Hanen, SCERTS, and ESDM
Many autism families encounter multiple therapy approaches and wonder how they differ, which has the strongest evidence, and what autistic self-advocates say about each. This article compares five relationship-based and naturalistic approaches.
Note: This is not medical advice. Consult a licensed clinician, BCBA, or developmental pediatrician before selecting a therapy approach.
Relationship Development Intervention (RDI)
RDI focuses on building "dynamic intelligence" — the ability to adapt to changing social situations — through guided parent-child interaction. Developed by Steven Gutstein. - Research summary: Emerging (limited RCT data; mostly case studies and parent reports) - Best suited for: Families who want to be primary agents of change; emphasizes parent coaching - Self-advocate perspectives: Mixed; some appreciate the relationship focus; others note concerns about normalizing autistic social differences
Floortime / DIR (Developmental, Individual Difference, Relationship-based)
Floortime follows the child's lead during play, expanding "circles of communication." Developed by Stanley Greenspan and Serena Wieder. - Research summary: Moderate (several RCTs showing gains in adaptive behavior and social-emotional development) - Best suited for: Young children; play-based; non-directive - Self-advocate perspectives: Generally more positive; child-led, avoids compliance training; autistic adults often prefer naturalistic approaches
Hanen (It Takes Two to Talk / More Than Words)
Hanen programs train parents and caregivers to support language development in naturalistic interactions. - Research summary: Moderate (strong evidence for parent-implemented language support) - Best suited for: Children with language delays; families who want practical communication strategies - Self-advocate perspectives: Generally positive; focuses on communication rather than behavior compliance
SCERTS (Social Communication, Emotional Regulation, Transactional Support)
SCERTS is a comprehensive framework that integrates goals from multiple approaches, focusing on social communication and emotional regulation across all environments. - Research summary: Emerging to moderate (framework widely used; component strategies have evidence) - Best suited for: School teams and multidisciplinary environments; works well alongside other approaches - Self-advocate perspectives: Positive; explicitly values autistic communication differences
ESDM (Early Start Denver Model)
ESDM combines Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) principles with relationship-based, play-focused interaction. Designed for children 12-48 months. - Research summary: Strong (multiple RCTs, including a landmark 2010 trial by Sally Rogers and Geraldine Dawson) - Best suited for: Young children (ages 1-4); intensive early intervention - Self-advocate perspectives: Mixed; the ABA component raises concerns for some self-advocates; modern ESDM practitioners emphasize naturalistic delivery
How to Choose
No single approach is right for every child or family. Key questions: 1. What does your child enjoy? (Play-based vs structured?) 2. How much family involvement is realistic? 3. What does your child's evaluation team recommend? 4. What does your autistic child want, if they can communicate preferences?
Consider asking providers: "What does your approach look like on a typical day?" and "How do you measure progress?"
A Note on ABA
ABA remains the most extensively researched autism intervention. Modern ABA has shifted toward naturalistic, child-led methods. If considering ABA, ask specifically about the type used (Discrete Trial Training vs Natural Environment Teaching vs Pivotal Response Training) and ensure the approach is play-based and avoids aversives.
Related Resources
Need More Personalized Help?
Our assistant can explain options and help you organize questions and paperwork. Your child's team and local agencies can advise on your situation.
Talk to Navigator →Keep every answer in one place.
Join the waitlist to save guides, decode your child’s plans, and get cited help whenever you need it.
Private beta · Free for families · You stay in control